Bethany Reservoir: A Comprehensive Guide to Angler’s Success

Nestled amidst the rolling hills of Byron, California, Bethany Reservoir is a 608-acre angler’s paradise. This state recreation area boasts a reputation for its largemouth bass populations, alongside catfish, sunfish, and the occasional striper surprise, making it a prime destination for both seasoned and casual anglers.

Fish You Can Expect to Catch

  1. Largemouth Bass: The undisputed stars of the show, lurking in the tules, rocky outcrops, and shallows. Crankbaits, spinnerbaits, jigs, and soft plastics are their kryptonite, especially near the dam, coves, and points.
  2. Channel Catfish: These bottom-dwellers thrive in deeper areas and near the dam, particularly at night. Nightcrawlers or cut bait fished on the bottom will get them interested.
  3. Bluegill and Redear Sunfish: These schooling fish are abundant in the shallows, ideal for kids or anyone using light tackle. Worms, crickets, or small jigs around the docks, lily pads, or submerged trees will have them nibbling.
  4. Striped Bass (Seasonal): During their migration season (October to May), stripers frequent the deeper areas near the dam. Troll lures or baitfish for a chance at a trophy striper.
  5. Pumpkinseed: These colorful sunfish are smaller than bluegill but offer feisty fights. Look for them near the edges and shallows with similar baits as sunfish.

Local Insights

Early mornings and evenings are prime times, especially for bass and catfish. The dam area, coves, and points are the most productive spots for bass, while the shallows near the dam and docks hold sunfish and catfish. Fish slowly and quietly for larger bass, especially during midday. Nightcrawlers or cut bait fished on the bottom near the dam at dusk and dawn are a surefire way to attract catfish. Sunfish are easy targets from the banks or shallow areas with simple baits like worms or crickets. Striper fishing is best during their migration months, so check seasonal regulations.

Unique Things to Pay Attention To

Bethany Reservoir is a popular park, so expect to share the space with boaters, swimmers, and hikers. Limited parking is available, especially on weekends and holidays. Arrive early. No gas-powered motors are allowed, but electric trolling motors are permitted. The reservoir is primarily stocked with fish, so don’t expect the same trophy potential as larger reservoirs. Respect the wildlife and leave no trace.

Specific Fishing Locations

  1. Dam Area: Cast towards the drop-off for catfish or fish near the edges for bass. Try trolling near the dam for stripers during their season.
  2. Cove Near the Boat Launch: This sheltered area is a haven for sunfish and smaller bass. Use bobbers with worms or crickets for relaxed fishing.
  3. Points with Tules and Rocks: These offer ambush points for larger bass. Pitch jigs or worms carefully and be prepared for a fight.
  4. Shallows Near the Dam and Docks: Look for sunfish and catfish cruising near the edges or around submerged structures. Simple baits like worms or crickets work wonders.
  5. Fishing Docks: Offer easy access for anglers of all abilities and are great for sunfish, catfish, and even the occasional small bass. Use live bait or lures for a chance at something bigger.

Check out our Gearlist for the gear we for trips like this

Our Gearlist account lists all of the gear we use. Discover our top picks, where to snag them, and stay informed with our regular updates.

Additional Tips

Grab a California Fishing License and an East Bay Regional Park District (EBRPD) Daily Fishing Access Permit. Rent a boat or kayak for exploring the entire reservoir and reaching hidden honey holes. Pack plenty of water, sunscreen, and snacks for your fishing adventure. Be prepared for changing weather conditions, especially during spring and fall.

Bethany Reservoir might not be the biggest fishery in the Bay Area, but it’s a hidden gem for bass enthusiasts and families seeking a relaxed fishing experience. With its diverse fish populations, stunning scenery, and easy access, Bethany Reservoir is the perfect place to cast a line, create memories, and maybe even land that trophy bass you’ve been dreaming of!