Puddingstone Lake: Unraveling the Depths of a Southern Californian Fishing Haven

Nestled in the scenic San Gabriel Valley, Puddingstone Lake, colloquially known as the “old mud puddle,” emerges as a captivating fishing destination. Offering a diverse fishery and a tranquil escape, this lake beckons anglers with promises of bass, trout, catfish, and more. In the heart of the San Dimas region, this SoCal gem has a lot to offer both seasoned anglers and those seeking a peaceful day by the water.

Latest Fish Plants

Fish here often?

  • Bookmark this page to check recent fish plant data before you head out on your trip.
  • Subscribe and get weekly California Fish Plant Data right in your inbox for the week ahead. We send out fish plant data for ALL fishing locations in California every Saturday at 7am PT🎣
  • Get additional subscriber-only data including πŸ“ˆ historical fish plant data and πŸ—ΊοΈ interactive maps with πŸ“ pins on our best spots at that location:

How To Read Fish Plant Graphs

To interpret fish plant graphs effectively, consider the following key elements:

  1. Blue Vertical Bars and Numbers:
    • Representation: The blue vertical bars on the graph represent individual fish plants.
    • Weight Measurement: The associated numbers indicate the total weight of the plants in pounds (lbs.) that occurred during a specific week.
    • Significance: Monitoring these bars helps identify weeks with higher planting activity, aiding anglers in selecting optimal times for fishing near recent plantings.
  2. Orange Trend Line:
    • Purpose: The orange trend line represents the moving average of all fish plant activities at the specified location.
    • Indicator of Activity: A rising trend line suggests a consistent increase in planting activity over the designated period. This indicates the potential for more catch opportunities and signifies a growing fish population over the weeks.
  3. Interpreting the Moving Average:
    • Upward Trend: A rising moving average implies an upward trajectory in planting activity, indicating an increasing number of fish being introduced into the area. This suggests a positive outlook for anglers, as it implies a larger and potentially more accessible fish population.
    • Downward Trend (Not Specified): The description does not provide information on the interpretation of a decreasing trend in the moving average. It might be beneficial to include information on what a decreasing trend could signify in terms of fishing prospects.
  4. No Data Present:
    • Possible Explanations: If no data is visible on the graph, it may indicate that the location had no fish plants in the last three months. Alternatively, the absence of data could be due to non-disclosure of fish plants for that location.
    • Natural Population: Some fishing areas in California rely on the natural growth of fish populations, and graphs may not show plants if this is the case.
  5. Graph Disclaimer:
    • Data Source: The graphs reflect a combination of publicly disclosed data and estimates. Some locations may disclose fish plants without specifying exact amounts.
    • Not Universal: Not all fishing areas have fish plants, and the natural growth of fish populations plays a significant role in many California fishing locations.

Understanding these elements will empower anglers to make informed decisions about when and where to fish based on historical fish plant data.

Note: If no data is present in the graph above, this location may not have had any plants the last 3 months, or may not have publicly disclosed plants. Graphs reflect both publicly disclosed data and estimates, as some locations disclose plants, but not exact amount.

Map & Fishing Location

Types of Fish You Can Expect to Catch Here

  1. Catfish Kings:
    • Channel catfish reign supreme, particularly during the warmer months from May to September. Nightcrawlers, stink bait, and cut bait prove effective, especially when presented near the lake bottom.
  2. Bass Bonanza:
    • Largemouth bass, the year-round residents, lurk in coves, weed beds, and around rocky structures. Prime times for action are the early mornings and evenings, with crankbaits, jigs, and plastic worms as their preferred lures.
  3. Trout Surprises:
    • Winter months (December to February) witness the stocking of rainbow trout. Mornings and evenings near inlets or deeper areas present opportunities for a thrilling fight. Matching the hatch becomes crucial for optimal results.
  4. Panfish Symphony:
    • Crappie and bluegill add a playful touch, especially near docks and shallows. Live minnows or small jigs become irresistible invitations for a tug-of-war, making it an ideal experience for families.
  5. Carp Giants:
    • Occasionally, monster carp make an appearance, offering anglers a challenge with their powerful runs and headstands. Landing them may not be easy, but the fight is undoubtedly worth it.

Local Insights:

  • Early Risers Rule:
    • The golden hour after sunrise and the last hour before sunset are magical, particularly for bass and catfish. The lake comes alive with activity, and fish rise to feed.
  • Live Bait Magic:
    • Nightcrawlers, minnows, or stink bait wield a powerful allure for catfish and crappie. Consider them irresistible snacks for these bottom feeders.
  • Lure Legends:
    • When targeting bass, experiment with different colors, retrieves, and types of lures like jigs, spinnerbaits, and worms. Trigger their feeding frenzy with unexpected choices.
  • Shore or Boat:
    • Both options are viable. The shoreline offers easy access and a relaxed atmosphere, while boats allow you to explore deeper waters and hidden coves.

Puddingstone Lake: A Historical Perspective

Originally dubbed the “old mud puddle,” Puddingstone Lake has evolved into a diverse fishery. Covering 250 acres when full, it transforms into an excellent destination during winter and spring, especially for trout enthusiasts. As colder weather arrives, the trout plants commence, offering generous catch rates for shoreliners and trollers alike. Other species, including largemouth bass, bluegill, and crappie, contribute to the lake’s multifaceted ecosystem.

Top 5 Tips for Anglers Fishing Here the First Time

  • Master the Seasonal Shifts:
    • Tailor your fishing strategy to seasonal variations. Different fish species exhibit unique behaviors during specific months, providing a strategic advantage for anglers.
  • Prime Locations and Times:
    • Focus your efforts around docks, underwater drop-offs, and areas with depths ranging from 40–50 feet in winter to 15–20 feet in early spring. Early mornings and evenings are opportune times for successful bass fishing.
  • Avoid the Boating Frenzy:
    • May through early September sees an influx of boating enthusiasts, leading to a challenging environment for anglers. Plan your visits during fall through spring, the prime time for a serene fishing experience.
  • Rainfall and Runoff Considerations:
    • The lake’s condition after rainfall significantly affects fishing. While intense rain muddies up the lake, moderate rain freshens it, providing an excellent view of the surrounding mountains.
  • Regulations Awareness:
    • Adhere to the speed limit of 35 mph and ensure your boat meets the specified length requirements. Be conscious of daily fishing and boating hours, and don’t forget the mandatory boat inspection for mussel certification.

Top 5 Strategies and Tactics for Maximum Fishing Success

  • Seasonal Adaptation:
    • Align your fishing strategy with seasonal shifts to optimize your chances of success. Different seasons demand varied approaches to cater to the changing behavior of fish.
  • Strategic Exploration of Shores and Structures:
    • Target bass and catfish around rocky areas and submerged trees, focusing on docks and bridges for optimal ambush points. Experiment with different depths and presentations for successful catches.
  • North Shore Trophy Catfish Pursuit:
    • Cast near the dam and inlets during the evenings for potential trophy catfish. Explore shallows for sunfish and keep an eye out for cruising carp, making this area great for beginners and families.
  • West Shore Solitude for Monster Catfish and Bass:
    • Enjoy the tranquility of the west shore and cast towards deeper waters for potential monster catfish and bass, especially during the mornings and evenings. Try live bait or cut bait near the bottom for optimal results.
  • Docks and Bridges Prime Fishing:
    • Utilize the structures of docks and bridges for prime ambush points for bass and crappie. Experiment with different depths and presentations to determine what works best.

Top 5 Recommendations on Fishing Gear

  • Channel Catfish Essentials:
    • Equip yourself with sturdy rods and reels suitable for catfish. Nightcrawlers, stink bait, and cut bait are essential components of your catfish arsenal.
  • Largemouth Bass Kit:
    • Invest in a reliable largemouth bass rod and reel combination. Crankbaits, jigs, and plastic worms should be part of your lure selection for enticing bass bites.
  • Rainbow Trout Gear:
    • Arm yourself with a dedicated trout rod and reel combination suitable for various sizes. Experiment with spinners, spoons, and PowerBait for enticing bites.
  • Crappie and Bluegill Tackle:
    • Lightweight tackle is crucial for crappie and bluegill. Invest in suitable rods and reels, and experiment with live minnows or small jigs for a thrilling experience.
  • Explore Our Gearlist for Precision:
    • Delve into our Gearlist account for precise recommendations on fishing gear tailored to Puddingstone Lake. Maximize your angling experience with tools used by seasoned experts.

Check out our Gearlist for the gear we for trips like this

Our Gearlist account lists all of the gear we use. Discover our top picks, where to snag them, and stay informed with our regular updates.

Puddingstone Lake: A Tapestry of Nature and Family Fun

Beyond its role as a fishing haven, Puddingstone Lake offers a portal to family fun, nature appreciation, and a touch of history. Picture yourself casting your line against a backdrop of rolling hills, oak trees, and the majestic San Gabriel Mountains. Breathe in the fresh air, soak in the views, and let your fishing adventure unfold in this diverse and memorable Southern Californian oasis.